.

.

December 30, 2006

A Circle of Quiet


A Circle of Quiet (The Crosswicks Journal – Book One) by Madeleine L’Engle
Nonfiction – Spirituality/Autobiography
Finished on 12/18/06
Rating: C- (2/10 Boring)

Maybe next December I should plan to limit my reading to thrillers and fluffy romances. Three disappointing books in a row makes me wonder if the fault lies in the book or, rather, in the distraction of the holiday season. Whatever the reason, I doubt I’ll be reading any more by L’Engle. I read A Wrinkle In Time a few years ago and didn’t think it was nearly as good as did some of my friends. This past summer I read Two-Part Invention (another Crosswicks Journal – Book Four) and it took well over 70 pages before I became interested in that. I think the main reason for my appreciation (and high rating) of that particular book was due to the subject matter. Dealing with my own grief this past year, I found comfort and validation in L’Engle’s words. Unfortunately, A Circle of Quiet failed to deliver the same emotional insights and I wound up skimming the majority of the book.

9 comments:

  1. Les, L'Engle is one of those writers I want so badly to love, but I just don't. I have tried book after book, and the only one I truly care about is her children's book, The Twenty-four Days Before Christmas. I can't get through her adult books, or her non-fiction pieces. I admire the woman, but not her writing. I actually feel much the same way about Stephen King. :<)

    I wouldn't blame the holidays. Sometimes it is just the books we pull off the shelves. I'll start a book I bought years ago, and wonder why I put money down for it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sorry you had another disappointing one. Hope the next one is good!!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I never quite became a huge fan either. I'm not sure why...

    ReplyDelete
  4. Oh dear, I recently purchased an adult novel by her. Your idea to read thrillers during the holidays sounds like a good one. I probably would have read more and enjoyed it more if I'd have been reading a mystery or a thriller.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I remember having a really hard time with Two-Part Invention; it seemed that she glorified (to an extreme) her relationship with Hugh. Of course, that was just my perspective looking in from the outside. Who am I to judge? But, when I read Circle of Quiet many years ago, I loved it. I think it has to be the right time for such a read, and as you suggest, NOW is not a quiet time. I think I read it in the summer. I've got to agree about reading a thriller: sometimes you just need the action of a good plot. I breezed through Whiteout by Ken Follett when I first came back from surgery and loved it for only engaging me in action, not emotion.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Nan - You said it just right. She's "one of those writers I want so badly to love." Oh, well. I've given her a good try. Having said that, Book 2 (The Summer of the Great-Grandmother) sounds a bit intriguing. Maybe I'll just listen to it on audio...

    SuziQ - The next book was good! I should have a review up for it in the next few days.

    Jenclair - I'm not sure why I'm not either. I can't point to anything specific.

    Booklogged - The thriller I just finished was excellent! Now if only I can remember to follow this plan (of reading thrillers during December) next year.

    Bellezza - I read most of book to and from Texas for my daughter's graduation. I'm sure I was distracted, but I was also stuck in a plane with nothing else to read. Who knows why it failed to entertain me. Off to see what Whiteout (Follett) is all about. Sound like a perfect read for today, as we're FINALLY getting some snow!!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Oh! I am sooo sorry to hear about that. My New Years wish to you is that ur year be filled with great books. Best of luck.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I'm almost done with this, and I must say, L'Engle is certainly not for everyone or on a whim. She's from a different time, if you know what I mean, and writes very intelligently, heady stuff. You can't have the TV on and read her. lol. With this book, I've enjoying learning about L'Engle as a person and her ideas about writing, creativity, etc., etc.

    M

    ReplyDelete
  9. Nessie - Thanks. I'm off to a good start so far. At least Circle of Quiet wasn't too long. ;)

    Monica - I know what you mean about reading L'Engle in a quiet atmosphere. That's why I thought taking the book on a plane would be helpful. Maybe she's just not one to read cover-to-cover. I'm glad you're enjoying it! Have you read Two-Part Invention? I really liked the second half of that one.

    ReplyDelete

I may not answer your comments in a timely fashion, but I always answer. Check back soon!