February 25, 2007


Middlesex by Jeffrey Eugenides
Contemporary Fiction
Finished on 2/16/07
Rating: 4.5/5 (Terrific!)
Chunkster Challenge #2

I was born twice: first, as a baby girl, on a remarkably smogless Detroit day in January of 1960; and then again, as a teenage boy, in an emergency room near Petoskey, Michigan, in August of 1974. Specialized readers may have come across me in Dr. Peter Luce’s study, “Gender Identity in 5-Alpha-Reductase Pseudohermaphrodites,” published in the Journal of Pediatric Endocrinology in 1975. Or maybe you’ve seen my photograph in chapter sixteen of the now sadly outdated Genetics and Heredity. That’s me on page 578, standing naked beside a height chart with a black box covering my eyes.

My birth certificate lists my name as Calliope Helen Stephanides. My most recent driver’s license (from the Federal Republic of Germany) records my first name simply as Cal. I’m a former field hockey goalie, long-standing member of the Save-the-Manatee Foundation, rare attendant at the Greek Orthodox liturgy, and, for most of my adult life, an employee of the U.S. State Department. Like Tiresias, I was first one thing and then another. I’ve been ridiculed by classmates,, guinea-pigged by doctors, palpated by specialists, and researched by the March of Dimes. A redheaded girl from Grosse Point fell in love with me, not knowing what I was. (Her brother liked me, too.) An army tank led me into urban battle once; a swimming pool turned me into myth; I’ve left my body in order to occupy others – and all this happened before I turned sixteen.

And so begins Jeffrey Eugenides’ epic saga (and winner of the 2003 Pulitzer Prize).

Wow. What an extraordinary book. I was captivated from the opening pages and hated when it came to an end. This is a coming-of-age story like nothing you've ever read. Vividly composed of multiple storylines with numerous characters, seamlessly crafted and narrated in an incredibly plausible manner, I continually stopped and wondered how much could be autobiographical; it reads like a beautiful memoir.

I’m not sure what I expected when I began reading, but I do know I was surprised it was so entertaining and mesmerizing. I loved the back-story centered around Calliope’s grandparents and how they met and came to immigrate to America. I loved all the historical details sprinkled throughout the narrative: silk farming, the Greco-Turkish War, the burning of Smyrna in 1922, Detroit during Prohibition, the Nation of Islam and W.D. Fard, and the Detroit Riots in 1967. I found this particular passage quite provocative and wondered if Eugenides had experienced it first-hand (he, too, was born in 1960 and grew up in Detroit):

To live in America, until recently, meant to be far from war. Wars happened in Southeast Asian jungles. They happened in Middle Eastern deserts. They happened, as the old song has it, over there. But then why, peeking out the dormer window, did I see, on the morning after our second night in the attic, a tank rolling by our front lawn? A green army tank, all alone in the long shadows of the morning, its enormous treads clanking against the asphalt. An armor-plated military vehicle encountering no greater obstacle than a lost roller skate. The tank rolled past the affluent homes, the gables and turrets, the porte cocheres. It stopped briefly at the stop sign. The gun turret looked both ways, like a driver’s ed student, and then the tank went on its way.

Another passage that helped set the scene of that particular period in history:

Of all my childhood memories, none has the magic, the pure dreaminess, of the night we heard a honk outside our house and looked out the window to see that a spaceship had landed in our driveway.

It had set down noiselessly next to my mother’s station wagon. The front lights flashed. The back end gave off a red glow. For thirty seconds nothing more happened. But then finally the window of the spaceship slowly retracted to reveal, instead of a Martian inside, Milton. He had shaved off his beard.

‘Get your mother,’ he called, smiling. ‘We’re going for a little ride.’

Not a spaceship then, but close: a 1967 Cadillac Fleetwood, as intergalactic a car as Detroit ever produced. (The moon shot was only a year away.) …

There has been lively discussion among fellow lit-bloggers regarding the merit of overzealous hype (deserved or undeserved) of recent book releases, leading me to consider my response to Jeffrey Eugenides' second novel. I knew absolutely nothing about Middlesex or its author prior to picking up the book early this month. I can’t even remember what prompted me to purchase it, but I’m sure it was based on someone’s glowing review (most likely a friend’s, since I rarely read book reviews prior to reading the book). I’m only vaguely familiar with Eugenides’ debut novel, The Virgin Suicides, but haven’t gotten around to reading it, nor have I seen the movie. (You can be sure I’ll do both now.) Middlesex was published in 2002, so whatever rave reviews followed its initial release slipped under my radar. Perhaps that's a good thing. Would I have found more enjoyment in The Thirteenth Tale had I waited until 2011 to read it? Perhaps. On the other hand, what about The Book Thief? Disregarding the hype, would I have simply forgotten to buy a copy and missed out on one of the best books ever? I’d like to believe that the quality of a great book lies simply in the author’s ability to educate and entertain. Whatever the case may be, I’m thrilled to have finally read Middlesex, as it did just that. This is so much more than a novel about genetic mutation. It's a marvelous, epic tale that shouldn't be missed.


  1. Okay, Les, you've convinced me! I've been picking up this book and then putting it down in bookstores for months now...undecided...should I? Or shouldn't I? Next time I pick it up, looks like I'll be walking out the door with it!

    Great review!

  2. I didn't like The Virgin Suicides, so that put me off of Middlesex, but now I want to read it...I'm also justifying the purchase by reminding myself that it would be another one off of the Pultizer list...I'm at 38..it would be a shame to stop now. Really happy you finally found a book that you liked; you had a frustrating time there for a while! Thanks for the review.

  3. I read this a while ago and really loved it. It was so unexpected. Actually I listened to it, and the narrator was absolutely fantastic.

  4. Lovely review, Les! Through the years I have owned several copies of "Middlesex" but always ended up giving them away because I found the size of the book intimidating. After reading how much you enjoyed the read, I have a good mind to look for it on audio. I am about 3/4ths into my first "chunkster" and although I got through the first half pretty easily, I will admit I am struggling with the middle! Fingers crossed I manage to complete it. The book's called "Shantaram".

  5. Great review! I kind of having been putting this one off because of the hype too. I may just have to move it up on the stacks now :)

  6. Both the size and the hype have intimidated me. I'm glad to see you enjoyed this one, Les. Might have to shove it up a bit higher on the stacks. Thanks for the terrific review!

  7. I read this one and loved it, too. Like others have said, how much I loved it was really unexpected. I had a similar suprised-by-love reaction to 'Motherless Brooklyn,' a book about a different sort of challenge altogether.

  8. Most excellent review. I read The Virgin Suicides and didn't care for it, but based on others' opinions (like yours), I will definitely give it a try.

  9. This is one of the books that has been languishing in my TBR pile - judging from your reaction, that's something I should remedy!

  10. The things you discover on blogs! Thanks so much for reading/reviewing and spreading the word on good books that we might never otherwise have considered.

  11. Wendy - Glad to be of help. I have a feeling you'll like this one.

    Bybee - I wonder if I'll like The Virgin Suicides. I do plan to read it one of these days... I think you should go ahead and buy a copy of Middlesex. You've read so many Pulitzers, it would be a shame to miss this one. And, honestly, I think it's one that calls for several re-reads.

    Marg - That's exactly what I felt. It was so unexpected. I wonder how many people have passed on it, perhaps with preconceived notions that it's distasteful?

    Lotus - Thank you so much! Don't be put off by the size of the novel. The pages truly fly and I never felt it lag at any point in my reading. I almost feel like I got away with a freebie for the Chunkster Challenge with this one! Good luck with Shantaram. I look forward to your review.

    Iliana - Thanks. Yes, do move it up. It'll probably make my Top Ten for 2007.

    Nancy - Don't let the size bother you. See my reply above to Lotus. Thanks for the pat on the back. It helps to have an in-house editor. ;)

    Bluestalking - Well, so far I haven't heard any negative remarks about the book, which is a good thing, I suppose. I know of Motherless Brooklyn, but haven't read it. Now I'll have to add it to my list. Thanks. I think.

    Andi - Oh, dear. That's two strikes against The Virgin Suicides. I may have to pass on it now. Yes, you must give Middlesex a try. I think you'd really enjoy it.

    Lesley - Don't let it languish any longer! It's a great read. Took me about 10 days, but I could have easily read it in half the time if life didn't keep interfering.

    Karen - You're more than welcome. It's as much fun for me as it is for all of you, I'm sure.

  12. Thanks for the review. I will have to pick this one up. It is a book I have picked up and then put down again--not sure why, as I have heard good things about it!

  13. Actually, I wish I had waiting a few years before I read The Thirteenth Tale - I was so disappointed! From the reviews, it seemed like the absolute perfect book for me, but it was both predictable and preposterous - not a good combination at all!


  14. A joke a teacher told me today, which may fit with this book's theme:

    A woman gave birth to a baby at the hospital and was told that she had a hermaphrodite.

    "What's that?" she cried.

    "It's when the baby is both a male and a female. You know, it has a penis AND a brain."

    (Told by a jaded woman, but still made me smile.)

  15. Great review, Lesley. Middlesex was one of my favorites the year I read it.

  16. Danielle - I suspect this is one of the books that a lot of people have picked up and put down repeatedly. Wonder why that is? I did it, too.

    Melanie - Sometimes it's just too difficult to resist temptation, especially when everyone around us is gushing about a particular book.

    Bellezza - Hehehehe! That's great! Thanks for the laughs.

    Literary Feline - Thanks so much. I wonder if he's working on something new.

  17. Stephanie5:20 PM

    Thanks for telling me that you wrote this review. I probably passed up reading it since I had the book sitting on my TBR shelf and like you mentioned, didn't want to read a review before actually reading this book. I am now 40 or so pages into Atonement by Ian McEwan and so far really like what I am reading!

  18. Stephanie - Yay!!!! I'm so happy to hear that you're enjoying Atonement. I should post a review. Need. More. Hours. In. A. Day!!


I may not answer your comments in a timely fashion, but I always answer. Check back soon!